Everything You Want to Know About St Augustine's Food Scene

​St. Augustine, Florida, the nation's oldest city, offers a rich tapestry of history, culture, and a vibrant culinary scene that reflects its diverse heritage. From traditional Spanish and Cuban flavors to contemporary American and international cuisines, the city's restaurants cater to a wide array of tastes and preferences. This guide provides an in-depth exploration of St. Augustine's dining landscape, highlighting notable establishments, their specialties, and what makes them stand out.​

1. The Blue Hen Café

Located at 223 W King St Ste A, The Blue Hen Café is a beloved spot for breakfast and lunch, known for its hearty Southern comfort food. Diners often praise dishes like buttermilk biscuits and gravy, shrimp and grits, and fried chicken. The café's warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. ​

2. Sunset Grille

Situated at 421 A1A Beach Blvd, Sunset Grille has garnered acclaim for its American cuisine and seafood offerings. With over 8,700 reviews, patrons frequently commend the New England Clam Chowder and the Datil Pepper Wings. The restaurant's location near the beach adds to its appeal, providing a relaxed dining experience. ​

3. Casa Benedetto's Ristorante

For those seeking Italian and Sicilian flavors, Casa Benedetto's Ristorante at 165 Vilano Rd offers a menu rich in traditional dishes. Diners have highlighted the juicy meatballs and authentic gelato, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to genuine Italian cuisine. 

4. Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila

Located at 1 Anderson Cir, Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila presents a fusion of Mexican and Latin flavors. With a 4.5 rating from over 860 reviews, popular dishes include the steak salad and a variety of tacos. The vibrant atmosphere and extensive tequila selection enhance the dining experience. ​

5. Crave

At 135 King St, Crave offers a health-conscious menu focusing on fresh, flavorful ingredients. With a perfect 5.0 rating from over 800 reviews, patrons rave about the salads and wraps, noting the emphasis on quality and taste. ​

6. The Columbia Restaurant

Established in 1905, The Columbia Restaurant at 98 St. George St is a historic establishment offering Spanish and Cuban cuisine. Recognized as "One of Florida's Top Restaurants" since 1967, diners can enjoy award-winning dishes in a setting adorned with hand-painted tiles and a Spanish-style fountain. ​

7. Collage Restaurant

For a fine dining experience, Collage Restaurant at 60 Hypolita St has received accolades such as being named among the "Top 100 Best Restaurants in America" by OpenTable. The menu features a blend of steakhouse and seafood options, with dishes like lobster and shrimp showcasing the chef's creativity. ​

8. The Floridian

Emphasizing Southern cuisine with a contemporary twist, The Floridian at 72 Spanish St offers dishes that highlight local and seasonal ingredients. The restaurant's commitment to sustainability and its cozy ambiance make it a standout in the historic district. ​

9. River & Fort Restaurant & Rooftop Lounge

Located at 12 Avenida Menendez, River & Fort provides a Southern continental-inspired menu featuring local seafood and steaks. The second and third-floor rooftops offer panoramic views of St. Augustine's historic sights, including the Bayfront and the Castillo de San Marcos. 

10. Sainte-George Restaurant

At 1 Saint George St, Sainte-George Restaurant offers a blend of American and European cuisines in a casual yet sophisticated setting. Diners can enjoy exquisitely crafted dishes while taking in views of the Castillo De San Marcos, enhancing the overall dining experience. ​

11. Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille

With a location at 46 Avenida Menendez, Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille brings a taste of New Orleans to St. Augustine. The menu features Cajun and Creole dishes, with favorites like jambalaya and shrimp étouffée. The lively atmosphere and waterfront views add to its charm.

12. Prohibition Kitchen

Situated at 119 St. George St, Prohibition Kitchen offers a gastropub experience with a nod to the 1920s. The menu includes gourmet burgers, craft cocktails, and live music, making it a popular spot for both dining and entertainment.​

13. The Ice Plant

Located at 110 Riberia St, The Ice Plant is renowned for its craft cocktails and farm-to-table menu. Set in a restored 1927 ice plant, the restaurant offers a unique historical ambiance alongside dishes like the half-pound Ice Plant Burger and fresh seafood options.​

14. Llama Restaurant

For a taste of Peruvian cuisine, Llama Restaurant at 415 Anastasia Blvd provides an intimate dining experience. Diners praise the creative dishes and excellent service, with menu highlights including ceviche and lomo saltado.​

15. Gas Full Service Restaurant

At 9 Anastasia Blvd, Gas Full Service Restaurant offers American fare with a focus on burgers and comfort food. The BBQ slaw burger and creative daily specials have earned it a loyal following among locals and tourists.​

16. O'Steen's Restaurant

A staple since 1965, O'Steen's at 205 Anastasia Blvd is famed for its fried shrimp and Southern sides. The no-frills setting and consistently delicious seafood have made it a must-visit spot in St. Augustine.

Best Places to Eat in St Augustine

St. Augustine’s culinary scene is as rich and diverse as its storied history. From casual beachside cafés to fine dining establishments in the heart of the historic district, the city offers a wide range of flavors to satisfy every palate. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, authentic Spanish and Cuban dishes, or innovative farm-to-table creations, there’s no shortage of exceptional restaurants to explore.

Beyond the food itself, St. Augustine’s dining experiences are elevated by breathtaking waterfront views, charming historic architecture, and a welcoming atmosphere that reflects the city’s warm hospitality. Whether you're a local looking for your next favorite spot or a visitor eager to immerse yourself in the local flavors, these restaurants offer unforgettable meals that capture the essence of St. Augustine.

No matter where you choose to dine, you’re sure to leave with a satisfied appetite and a deeper appreciation for this beautiful, historic city—one delicious bite at a time.